Comparisons
MSC (wild fish) vs ASC (farmed fish): which is better for the animal?
MSC (wild fish) and ASC (farmed fish) compared for fish: on 6 of 8 questions MSC (wild fish) is higher, on 1 ASC (farmed fish) is higher, on 1 they are equal. The guaranteed level is compared.
| Question | MSC (wild fish) | ASC (farmed fish) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lifespan | 1-4 | 1 | same guaranteed level, range differs |
| Mother and young | 4 | 1 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Freedom of movement | 4 | 2 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Resting place | 4 | 1 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Outdoors | 4 | 3 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Physical interventions | 4 | 3 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| The final journey | 4 | 1 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Death | 1 | 2-3 | higher: ASC (farmed fish) |
Level 1 is the lowest, the top level of the question is the best. A range such as 2-3 means our sources do not settle on one level.
Where the two differ
Lifespan
MSC (wild fish): Level 1 to 4
Depends on the fish: level 1 to 4. Only level 1 is guaranteed (Until it is big enough to be used. It may still be very young).
ASC (farmed fish): Level 1
Farmed fish are slaughtered once they reach eating size. At Knospe trout and salmon this means at least 15 to 24 months of keeping; the carp is harvested after about three summers. Wild fish live free until they are caught. They may be caught young or old and no rule sets an age, so wild catch is at 1 to 4.
Mother and young
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
The wild fish grows up in the wild, without a hatchery. The step comes from biology, not from a rule.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 1
The eggs are taken from the parent fish and hatched in a hatchery, and the young never see their parents. ASC allows hormones to trigger spawning, Naturland names natural reproduction as its aim.
Freedom of movement
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
A wide natural pond in which at least half of the growth comes from natural food. That is the case for the Knospe and Naturland carp. For wild fish the step comes from biology: it lives free in the sea, a lake or a river until it is caught.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 2
At most 25 kg of fish per cubic metre: that is how Norwegian law caps density for salmon in sea pens. It applies to ASC salmon from Norway, and ASC itself sets no lower limit.
Resting place
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
The wild fish lives in its natural habitat. The step comes from biology, not from a rule.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 1
The law prescribes no structures and no particular floor. A tank without hiding places is allowed. For Naturland trout and salmon, near-natural ground is only a target, so this step applies there too.
Outdoors
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
Outdoors in natural water for the whole growing time: that is how it is for carp in a natural pond, at Knospe and Naturland. For wild fish the step comes from biology: it lives free in the sea, a lake or a river until it is caught.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 3
Outdoors in some phases of life: Knospe and Naturland keep trout and salmon in ponds, tanks and net pens outdoors, with closed recirculation systems only from egg to fry. ASC salmon from Norway first grows up in tanks on land and then in open net pens in the sea. This step comes from the farming system, not from a choice the fish can make.
Physical interventions
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
Nothing is changed on or done to the wild fish before it is caught. The step comes from biology, not from a rule.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 3
Interventions on live fish are banned: Norwegian law forbids carrying out interventions on live fish or removing parts of their body. That applies to ASC salmon from Norway.
The final journey
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
The wild fish is not driven alive to a slaughterhouse; it dies at the catch or on board. How it dies is covered by the question on death.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 1
Live fish may be transported up to 10 hours: Knospe and Naturland allow 10 hours at most, and Naturland in a well boat up to 72. For ASC salmon from Norway we found no maximum duration, neither at ASC nor in Norwegian transport law.
Death
MSC (wild fish): Level 1
Most wild fish that are alive when landed suffocate in air or on ice or are gutted alive. This holds for wild catch without a label and with MSC; the MSC label has no rule on this.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 2 to 3
Depending on the farm, level 2 to 3. Only level 2 is guaranteed (It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick).
Sources
- Wild catch: the fish lives free in the sea, a lake or a river until it is caught (biology, no rule)
- FishBase: common carp, highest reported age (38 years, ref. 72479)
- LfL Bayern: leaflet on carp pond farming (Germany)
- Naturland standards for organic aquaculture 05/2026
- Norway: aquaculture operations regulation FOR-2008-06-17-822, last amended FOR-2026-01-25-85 (§ 25 stocking density, § 31 interventions, § 34 stunning)
- ASC Farm Standard V1.0.1A2, August 2026
- Open Food Facts: Coop Qualité & Prix ASC salmon fillet without skin, origin Norway (entry 2114494014158, edited 2 Apr 2026)
- Norway: Norwegian Veterinary Institute, Fiskehelserapporten 2024 (fish health report): salmon and rainbow trout first in fresh water on land, then at sea
- James et al. 2025: Humane stunning or stun/killing in the slaughter of wild-caught finfish (Animal Welfare 34, e33, doi 10.1017/awf.2023.30)
- Norway: regulation on commercial transport of animals FOR-2012-02-08-139, last amended FOR-2023-05-09-678 (§ 2 scope, § 9 travel time; no maximum for fish)
- MSC Fisheries Standard v3.1