Fish · Outdoors
Do farmed fish live outdoors?
The law prescribes no access to natural water. Level at the front: 4 standards, among them Wild-caught (no label), MSC wild catch (Fisheries Standard v3.1) and Knospe carp (natural pond). Weakest: Legal minimum for farmed fish (Animal Welfare Ordinance, TSchV).
Why it is like this
An indoor tank is allowed. Knospe and Naturland keep trout and salmon outdoors and carp in ponds, with closed recirculation systems only in the juvenile stage.
What the labels say
| Standard | Level |
|---|---|
| Legal minimum for farmed fish (Animal Welfare Ordinance, TSchV) | 1 Never. A bright barn is enough |
| Wild-caught (no label) | 4 On almost every day |
| MSC wild catch (Fisheries Standard v3.1) | 4 On almost every day |
| ASC farmed salmon (Farm Standard or Salmon Standard v1.4) | 3 On a few days a week |
| Knospe trout and salmon (tanks, net pens) | 3 On a few days a week |
| Knospe carp (natural pond) | 4 On almost every day |
| Naturland aquaculture trout and salmon (pond, net pens) | 3 On a few days a week |
| Naturland aquaculture carp (pond) | 4 On almost every day |
How we read the levels
- Never. A bright barn is enough.
- Never, but it feels fresh air in the barn.
- On a few days a week.
- On almost every day.
Level 1: Never. A bright barn is enough.
Applies to: Legal minimum for farmed fish (Animal Welfare Ordinance, TSchV)
Nothing is prescribed about outdoors: the law requires no access to natural water or light, and an indoor tank is allowed.
The animal welfare ordinance names neither outdoor keeping nor light for fish (Art. 98). For fish we read the question as: does the fish live in natural water? A fish that spends its whole life in a closed recirculation system indoors belongs at this step. The step describes the farming system the law allows.
Level 3: On a few days a week.
Applies to: ASC farmed salmon (Farm Standard or Salmon Standard v1.4), Knospe trout and salmon (tanks, net pens) and Naturland aquaculture trout and salmon (pond, net pens)
Outdoors in some phases of life: Knospe and Naturland keep trout and salmon in ponds, tanks and net pens outdoors, with closed recirculation systems only from egg to fry. ASC salmon from Norway first grows up in tanks on land and then in open net pens in the sea. This step comes from the farming system, not from a choice the fish can make.
At Naturland, closed recirculation systems are allowed only from egg to fry (Part B III). At Knospe, tanks and net pens stand outdoors, but the fish do not live entirely in a natural pond, since plastic tanks are allowed for up to half of life. That lies between steps 3 and 4. At Knospe and Naturland the farming system is written in the standard. For ASC salmon the step rests on the farming system in Norway: according to the Norwegian Veterinary Institute's fish health report 2024, salmon and rainbow trout spend the first part of their life in fresh water at hatcheries on land and then live in sea water. The Norwegian aquaculture regulation caps density in every unit except slaughter pens and closed units (§ 25) and also names closed units that depend on water intake and outflow (§ 4 no. 17). So it does not require open water, and the step rests on how salmon is farmed in Norway today. We did not evaluate a farming system in the ASC standard.
Level 4: On almost every day.
Applies to: Wild-caught (no label), MSC wild catch (Fisheries Standard v3.1), Knospe carp (natural pond) and Naturland aquaculture carp (pond)
Outdoors in natural water for the whole growing time: that is how it is for carp in a natural pond, at Knospe and Naturland. For wild fish the step comes from biology: it lives free in the sea, a lake or a river until it is caught.
Naturland requires rearing in ponds and no artificial containers; only holding before slaughter of up to 8 weeks is exempt (Part B II 2.2). Knospe: carp in a natural pond, half the growth from natural food (5.7.11.3). For wild fish without a label and with MSC the step comes from biology, not from a rule: the fish lives free until it is caught. MSC has no welfare rule and changes nothing here.
What stays open
There is no rule on this that we found. Wild catch and MSC have no keeping system. By our reading ASC prescribes no farming system, so ASC salmon from Norway counts with the usual system there: tanks on land first, then open net pens in the sea.
Sources
- Norway: Norwegian Veterinary Institute, Fiskehelserapporten 2024 (fish health report): salmon and rainbow trout first in fresh water on land, then at sea
- Open Food Facts: Coop Qualité & Prix ASC salmon fillet without skin, origin Norway (entry 2114494014158, edited 2 Apr 2026)
- Wild catch: the fish lives free in the sea, a lake or a river until it is caught (biology, no rule)
- Animal Welfare Ordinance SR 455.1, as of 1 Feb 2026 (seen 21 Nov 2026)
- Norway: aquaculture operations regulation FOR-2008-06-17-822, last amended FOR-2026-01-25-85 (§ 25 stocking density, § 31 interventions, § 34 stunning)
- Bio Suisse standards 2026, part II (Knospe)
- Naturland standards for organic aquaculture 05/2026
- MSC Fisheries Standard v3.1
- ASC Farm Standard V1.0.1A2, August 2026
- Everything on Fish
- How old are fish when they are killed for food?
- Do farmed fish ever see their parents?
- How much space do farmed fish have?
- What does a farmed fish's habitat look like?
- What treatments do farmed fish get?
- How long are live fish transported?
- How are fish killed?
- Label: Legal minimum
- Label: Wild fish without a label
- Label: MSC (wild fish)
- Label: ASC (farmed fish)
- Label: Knospe (Bio Suisse)
- Label: Naturland aquaculture