Comparisons
Wild-caught fish vs ASC (farmed salmon): which is better for the animal?
Wild-caught fish and ASC (farmed salmon) compared for fish: on 6 of 8 questions Wild-caught fish is higher, on 0 ASC (farmed salmon) is higher, on 2 they are equal. The guaranteed level is compared.
| Question | Wild-caught fish | ASC (farmed salmon) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lifespan | 1-4 | 1 | same guaranteed level, range differs |
| Mother and young | 4 | 1 | higher: Wild-caught fish |
| Freedom of movement | 4 | 1 | higher: Wild-caught fish |
| Resting place | 4 | 1 | higher: Wild-caught fish |
| Outdoors | 4 | 3 | higher: Wild-caught fish |
| Physical interventions | 4 | 1 | higher: Wild-caught fish |
| The final journey | 4 | 1 | higher: Wild-caught fish |
| Death | 1 | 1 | equal |
Level 1 is the lowest, the top level of the question is the best. A range such as 2-3 means our sources do not settle on one level.
Where the two differ
Lifespan
Wild-caught fish: Level 1 to 4
Depends on the fish: level 1 to 4. Only level 1 is guaranteed (Until it is big enough to be used. It may still be very young).
ASC (farmed salmon): Level 1
A fish is killed when it is caught or reaches eating size, and no law or label we read sets an age.
Mother and young
Wild-caught fish: Level 4
The natural state: a wild fish spawns in the sea or river, and the young grow up there. This applies to wild fish without a label and with an MSC label.
ASC (farmed salmon): Level 1
Farmed salmon hatch in a hatchery. The RSPCA Assured salmon standard has rules for eggs, newly hatched fish and fry, and none about contact with the parent fish.
Freedom of movement
Wild-caught fish: Level 4
The top of the range is open water with room to roam. This is how wild fish live until they are caught.
ASC (farmed salmon): Level 1
The law sets no stocking limit for farmed fish, and the ASC salmon standard in force sets none either. That is Level 1.
Resting place
Wild-caught fish: Level 4
Several natural structures to choose from: wild fish in the sea.
ASC (farmed salmon): Level 1
A sea pen is a net hanging in open water. The RSPCA Assured salmon standard sets the depth of the net but we read no rule on structures or a natural bottom.
Outdoors
Wild-caught fish: Level 4
Outside in natural water for the whole growing period. This is how wild fish live.
ASC (farmed salmon): Level 3
Farmed salmon spend their first stage in freshwater tanks in a hatchery and then live in net pens in the open sea. Every farmed salmon row is at Level 3: the law, ASC, RSPCA Assured and organic salmon.
Physical interventions
Wild-caught fish: Level 4
Nothing is done to the animal until it is caught. This is the wild fish. Injuries from nets and bycatch are not counted here.
ASC (farmed salmon): Level 1
The law has no rule on procedures for farmed fish, and neither does the ASC salmon standard. That is Level 1.
The final journey
Wild-caught fish: Level 4
No transport of live fish: the wild fish dies in the net or on board. It reaches land dead or dying.
ASC (farmed salmon): Level 1
No law or label we read sets a time limit for transporting live fish. That is Level 1.
Sources
- Wild catch: the fish lives free in the sea, a lake or a river until it is caught. It may be caught young or old, and no rule sets an age. This level comes from the biology of the fish, not from a document
- Wild fish: the levels come from the biology of the fish, not from a written rule; the fish lives free in sea, lake or river until it is caught
- Same Regs, reg 3 (reg 3(2)(a): fish, reptiles and amphibians are not 'farmed animals', so the Regulations do not apply to fish)
- Welfare of Farmed Animals (Scotland) Regulations 2010 (SSI 2010/388), reg 3(2)(a): fish are not farmed animals under these Regulations
- RSPCA welfare standards for farmed Atlantic salmon, May 2024
- ASC Salmon Standard v1.4, issued 5 September 2022, effective 1 February 2023 (https://peru.controlunion.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2023/08/9__asc-salmon-standard-v1_4-final.pdf)
- Commission Reg (EC) 889/2008 as retained, Annex XIIIa (aquaculture stocking densities)
- ASC Farm Standard V1.1 (ASC-STD-001), published 1 November 2026, effective 1 February 2027
- Production system of farmed Atlantic salmon: hatchery and freshwater stages, then open sea net pens, as described in the RSPCA welfare standards for farmed Atlantic salmon
- Soil Association Organic Standards GB, Aquaculture v1.9, 9 November 2026
- Council Reg (EC) 1/2005 as retained, Annex I Chapter V (transport times); Transport Order 2006 art 5 only sets offences
- Council Reg (EC) 834/2007 as retained, Art 15 (aquaculture rules)