Comparisons
RSPCA Assured vs ASC (farmed salmon): which is better for the animal?
RSPCA Assured and ASC (farmed salmon) compared for fish: on 3 of 8 questions RSPCA Assured is higher, on 0 ASC (farmed salmon) is higher, on 5 they are equal. The guaranteed level is compared.
| Question | RSPCA Assured | ASC (farmed salmon) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lifespan | 1 | 1 | equal |
| Mother and young | 1 | 1 | equal |
| Freedom of movement | 3 | 1 | higher: RSPCA Assured |
| Resting place | 1 | 1 | equal |
| Outdoors | 3 | 3 | equal |
| Physical interventions | 3-4 | 1 | higher: RSPCA Assured |
| The final journey | 1 | 1 | equal |
| Death | 3 | 1 | higher: RSPCA Assured |
Level 1 is the lowest, the top level of the question is the best. A range such as 2-3 means our sources do not settle on one level.
Where the two differ
Freedom of movement
RSPCA Assured: Level 3
RSPCA Assured salmon may be stocked at up to 17 kg of fish per cubic metre of water in sea pens. Organic salmon under the retained regulation is capped at 10 kg per cubic metre.
ASC (farmed salmon): Level 1
The law sets no stocking limit for farmed fish, and the ASC salmon standard in force sets none either. That is Level 1.
Physical interventions
RSPCA Assured: Level 3 to 4
Depending on the farm, level 3 to 4. Only level 3 is guaranteed (Only if a particular animal needs treatment itself).
ASC (farmed salmon): Level 1
The law has no rule on procedures for farmed fish, and neither does the ASC salmon standard. That is Level 1.
Death
RSPCA Assured: Level 3
RSPCA Assured salmon must be stunned or killed by a method that makes the fish insensible quickly, and six methods are banned outright, including ice slurry and carbon dioxide.
ASC (farmed salmon): Level 1
Wild-caught fish, with or without the MSC label, have no killing rule in any law or label we read. For farmed fish, by our reading, the law on killing does not require stunning either: only the general duty to spare avoidable pain (Article 3(1)) applies. ASC, a label for farmed fish only, is at this level too until its new standard applies in 2027.
Sources
- RSPCA welfare standards for farmed Atlantic salmon, May 2024
- Commission Reg (EC) 889/2008 as retained, Annex XIIIa (aquaculture stocking densities)
- Same Regs, reg 3 (reg 3(2)(a): fish, reptiles and amphibians are not 'farmed animals', so the Regulations do not apply to fish)
- ASC Salmon Standard v1.4, issued 5 September 2022, effective 1 February 2023 (https://peru.controlunion.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/5/2023/08/9__asc-salmon-standard-v1_4-final.pdf)
- ASC Farm Standard V1.1 (ASC-STD-001), published 1 November 2026, effective 1 February 2027
- Welfare of Farmed Animals (Scotland) Regulations 2010 (SSI 2010/388), reg 3(2)(a): fish are not farmed animals under these Regulations
- MSC Fisheries Standard version 3.1, web pages only (the standard PDF itself was not found)
- Council Reg (EC) 1099/2009 as retained, Arts 1, 2 and 4 (the stunning duty does not cover fish)