Comparisons
Organic (Debio, EU) vs MSC (wild fish): which is better for the animal?
Organic (Debio, EU) and MSC (wild fish) compared for fish: on 1 of 8 questions Organic (Debio, EU) is higher, on 6 MSC (wild fish) is higher, on 1 they are equal. The guaranteed level is compared.
| Question | Organic (Debio, EU) | MSC (wild fish) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lifespan | 1 | 1-4 | same guaranteed level, range differs |
| Mother and young | 1 | 4 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Freedom of movement | 3 | 4 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Resting place | 1 | 4 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Outdoors | 3 | 4 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Physical interventions | 3 | 4 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| The final journey | 1 | 4 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Death | 2 | 1 | higher: Organic (Debio, EU) |
Level 1 is the lowest, the top level of the question is the best. A range such as 2-3 means our sources do not settle on one level.
Where the two differ
Lifespan
Organic (Debio, EU): Level 1
Farmed salmon and trout, ASC and organic included, count here. No law or label we opened sets an age or size at slaughter for farmed fish, so nothing above rung 1 is proven. Wild fish, with or without MSC, start here too: a wild fish may be caught young, and no rule sets an age.
MSC (wild fish): Level 1 to 4
Depends on the fish: level 1 to 4. Only level 1 is guaranteed (Until it is big enough to be used. It may still be very young).
Mother and young
Organic (Debio, EU): Level 1
Farmed salmon and trout, ASC and organic included, count here. No law or label we opened says anything about parents and young for farmed fish, so nothing above rung 1 is proven.
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
A wild fish spawns in the sea and the young grow up there. No farmed fish reaches this.
Freedom of movement
Organic (Debio, EU): Level 3
Organic: salmon and trout in sea net pens are held to 10 kg per cubic metre, about 1 percent of the water. Norwegian organic fish is mostly salmon grown out in such pens.
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
The open sea. A wild fish has all the space there is.
Resting place
Organic (Debio, EU): Level 1
Farmed salmon and trout, ASC and organic included, count here. No law or label we opened gives a fish in a sea pen a place to rest.
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
Wild fish live in the sea, with all the structure the sea has.
Outdoors
Organic (Debio, EU): Level 3
Farmed salmon and trout, ASC and organic included, count here. They start in tanks on land and then grow out in open net pens in the sea, under the open sky. This rung comes from that farming system, not from a choice the fish can make.
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
Wild fish live in natural water for their whole life.
Physical interventions
Organic (Debio, EU): Level 3
Farmed salmon and trout, ASC and organic included, count here. Cuts and removal of body parts on live fish are banned, except marking and operations by a vet or fish health biologist for fish health reasons.
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
Nothing is done to a wild fish before it is caught. Injuries in the net and bycatch are not counted here.
The final journey
Organic (Debio, EU): Level 1
Farmed salmon and trout, ASC and organic included, count here. No written rule limits how long live fish may be carried to slaughter.
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
A wild fish is not moved alive. It reaches land dead or dying.
Death
Organic (Debio, EU): Level 2
Farmed fish must be stunned before they are killed, by a blow to the head, a medicine or another suitable method. The law does not mention fear beforehand.
MSC (wild fish): Level 1
Most wild fish landed alive die by suffocation in air, or by suffocation and gutting without stunning. We found no stunning rule for catches.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) 2018/848, organic production (Annex II)
- Akvakulturdriftsforskriften (FOR-2008-06-17-822)
- Biology of wild fish: lives in the wild until caught, young or old
- Product nature carried over from the German table (wild fish), not a written rule
- Implementing Regulation (EU) 2020/464, organic detailed rules
- Norwegian Veterinary Institute: Fiskehelserapporten 2024 (fish health report)
- Forskrift om næringsmessig transport av dyr (FOR-2012-02-08-139)
- MSC Fisheries Standard v3.1 (22 July 2024), searched for welfare, stunning and slaughter
- lovdata.no
- peru.controlunion.com
- publications.europa.eu
- publications.europa.eu
- vetinst.no
- lovdata.no
- fishcount.org.uk
- lovdata.no
- msc.org