Comparisons
Legal minimum (law) vs MSC (wild-caught fish): which is better for the animal?
Legal minimum (law) and MSC (wild-caught fish) compared for fish: on 1 of 8 questions Legal minimum (law) is higher, on 6 MSC (wild-caught fish) is higher, on 1 they are equal. The guaranteed level is compared.
| Question | Legal minimum (law) | MSC (wild-caught fish) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lifespan | 1 | 1-4 | same guaranteed level, range differs |
| Mother and young | 1 | 4 | higher: MSC (wild-caught fish) |
| Freedom of movement | 2 | 4 | higher: MSC (wild-caught fish) |
| Resting place | 1 | 4 | higher: MSC (wild-caught fish) |
| Outdoors | 3 | 4 | higher: MSC (wild-caught fish) |
| Physical interventions | 3 | 4 | higher: MSC (wild-caught fish) |
| The final journey | 1 | 4 | higher: MSC (wild-caught fish) |
| Death | 2 | 1 | higher: Legal minimum (law) |
Level 1 is the lowest, the top level of the question is the best. A range such as 2-3 means our sources do not settle on one level.
Where the two differ
Lifespan
Legal minimum (law): Level 1
The fish is caught or harvested as soon as it is big enough for the market. Plaice can live up to 50 years, sole 26 and herring 25 (FishBase). We found no figure for the age at which they are caught. No law or label we read sets an age for farmed fish, so every farmed fish row sits here, ASC salmon from Norway and organic fish included. Wild fish starts here too, because it may be caught young.
MSC (wild-caught fish): Level 1 to 4
Depends on the fish: level 1 to 4. Only level 1 is guaranteed (Until it is big enough to be used. It may still be very young).
Mother and young
Legal minimum (law): Level 1
The eggs are taken from the parent fish and hatched in a hatchery, and the young never meet their parents. EU organic requires young stock from organic broodstock. Neither Dutch nor Norwegian law has a rule on this, so the law sits here, and ASC salmon and organic fish with it.
MSC (wild-caught fish): Level 4
The natural state: a wild fish spawns in the sea or river, and the young grow up there. This applies to wild fish with and without MSC.
Freedom of movement
Legal minimum (law): Level 2
Turn around and stretch. EU organic sets maximum stocking densities: 25 kg of trout per cubic metre, 20 kg of salmon in fresh water, 10 kg of salmon in sea pens and 10 kg of pangasius. Trout at 25 kg sits on this rung. ASC salmon and salmon without a label sit here too: both are farmed in Norway, where the law allows at most 25 kg of salmon per cubic metre.
MSC (wild-caught fish): Level 4
Run and play. This is how a wild fish lives: free in open water.
Resting place
Legal minimum (law): Level 1
A simple spot: fish in tanks or pens have no lying place in the usual sense. Neither Dutch nor Norwegian law has a rule, so the law sits here, and ASC salmon and organic fish with it.
MSC (wild-caught fish): Level 4
Several soft spots, so the fish can choose. This applies to wild fish, which move through open water.
Outdoors
Legal minimum (law): Level 3
Outside in some life phases. Salmon with and without ASC sits here: salmon first grow up in tanks and then move to open net pens in the sea.
MSC (wild-caught fish): Level 4
Outside in natural water the whole time: this is wild fish, with and without MSC.
Physical interventions
Legal minimum (law): Level 3
Only if a particular animal needs treatment: Norwegian law bans operations on live fish except marking and work by a vet or fish health biologist, and salmon from Norway, with and without ASC, sits here. For fish farmed in the Netherlands, Dutch law also bans physical interventions unless a vet finds them necessary or a decree allows them, and no decree names fish.
MSC (wild-caught fish): Level 4
The animal keeps everything it was born with. This applies to wild fish.
The final journey
Legal minimum (law): Level 1
After a long journey: EU transport law sets no time limit for fish, and Norwegian transport law sets none either. The law sits here, and ASC and organic with it.
MSC (wild-caught fish): Level 4
No journey. A wild fish dies where it is caught, though hauling and landing can take hours.
Death
Legal minimum (law): Level 2
Stunned before killing, but fear before is possible: EU organic requires immediate unconsciousness, Dutch law requires eel to be stunned, and Norwegian law requires farmed fish to be stunned. Salmon from Norway sits here, with or without ASC: the stricter ASC rules bind all farms only from May 2028.
MSC (wild-caught fish): Level 1
Killed however is easiest. EU law gives fish only a general rule: spare them avoidable pain. It sets no stunning duty, so wild fish mostly die from being crushed in the net or by suffocation, over minutes or hours. Dutch law adds a stunning duty only for eel. The farmed salmon without a label sold here comes from Norway, where stunning is required (rung 2).
Sources
- FishBase: plaice (Pleuronectes platessa), maximum reported age
- FishBase: common sole (Solea solea), maximum reported age
- FishBase: Atlantic herring (Clupea harengus), maximum reported age
- CBS StatLine table 83622NED: Visserij en aquacultuur, hoeveelheid vis, schaal- en schelpdieren (annual 2024, final)
- Akvakulturdriftsforskriften (FOR-2008-06-17-822), Norwegian aquaculture regulation, paras 25, 31 and 34, as read for our Norway table
- Regulation (EU) 2018/848, Annex II Part II (livestock), original text
- Wild catch: the fish lives free until caught (our own reading)
- MSC Fisheries Standard v3.0 (no welfare rule for capture or killing)
- Implementing Regulation (EU) 2020/464, Articles 2, 9, 22 and Annexes I and II
- PLUS, product page Vis Marine zalmfilets: ASC logo, salmon farmed in Norway in open aquaculture
- PLUS, product page Zalmfilet met huid 500 g: no ASC, origin Norway, farmed in the fjords of Norway
- ASC Farm Standard V1.0.1A2 (August 2026), indicators 4.1.1.12, 4.1.3.2 to 4.1.3.6
- Besluit houders van dieren (Wettenbank BWBR0035217), articles 1.6, 1.11, 1.20, 2.2 to 2.5, 2.12, 2.17, 2.28, 2.30-2.46, 2.50, 2.71, 5.1, 5.10 and 5.11
- Wet dieren art. 2.8 (physical interventions banned unless veterinary necessity or designated) with Besluit diergeneeskundigen art. 2.2 (poultry; beak treatment was phased out from 1 September 2018 and is now only possible under the temporary exemption in Regeling diergeneeskundigen art. 7.3, which ended for laying hens on 1 January 2019, see stcrt), 2.3 (pigs: castration, tail docking up to 4 days, teeth filing up to 7 days, the last two only after injuries are seen and other measures failed), 2.4 (cattle: dehorning, nose ring for breeding bulls), 2.7 (no unnecessary pain)
- Regulation (EC) No 1/2005, Annex I Chapter V points 1.2, 1.4, 2.1
- Forskrift om næringsmessig transport av dyr (FOR-2012-02-08-139), Norwegian animal transport regulation, as read for our Norway table
- Fishcount estimates (no welfare rule for killing wild-caught fish)
- Mood and Brooke 2024, global numbers of wild-caught fish
- Dyrevelferdsloven (LOV-2009-06-19-97), Norwegian animal welfare act, as read for our Norway table
- Regulation (EC) No 1099/2009, Article 4(1) and 4(4) (stunning duty for mammals and birds); Article 1(1): for fish only Article 3(1) applies (spare avoidable pain, distress or suffering), so EU law has no stunning duty for fish
- Good Fish Foundation, method of the VISwijzer (sustainability only)