Fish · Outdoors
Do farmed fish live outdoors?
Usual: no duty to be outdoors; the young live in hatcheries indoors. Level at the front: Wild catch with no label and MSC. Weakest: Farmed fish (legal minimum).
Why it is like this
Spanish law has none for fish. Under EU organic young fish live in hatcheries and nurseries, and closed recirculation farms are banned otherwise. Wild fish live outdoors for the whole life.
What the labels say
| Standard | Level |
|---|---|
| Wild catch with no label | 4 On almost every day |
| MSC | 4 On almost every day |
| Farmed fish (legal minimum) | 1 Never. A bright barn is enough |
| ASC (aquaculture) | 3 On a few days a week |
| Acuicultura ecológica (EU organic) | 2 Never, but it feels fresh air in the barn |
How we read the levels
- Never. A bright barn is enough.
- Never, but it feels fresh air in the barn.
- On a few days a week.
- On almost every day.
Level 1: Never. A bright barn is enough.
Applies to: Farmed fish (legal minimum)
Spanish law asks nothing about outdoors for farmed fish, so level 1 is the guarantee. Many sea cages are in open water, which the law does not require.
RD 348/2000 Art. 3 b) leaves fish out of its Annex I specifications; only the general duty of Art. 3 a) applies. Where the law says nothing, it is level 1. Where a farm really keeps its fish is practice, not rule. ASC salmon is at level 3 because of how salmon are farmed (see level 3).
Level 2: Never, but it feels fresh air in the barn.
Applies to: Acuicultura ecológica (EU organic)
Covered or in a hall with fresh water flow: young fish live like this in hatcheries and nurseries, also under EU organic, which bans closed recirculation farms except hatcheries and nurseries.
Reg 2018/848 Annex II Part III 3.1.5.1: closed recirculation facilities prohibited except hatcheries and nurseries; 3.1.5.2: artificial heating or cooling only in hatcheries and nurseries; 3.1.5.5 (b): land units have at least 10 percent of the perimeter with natural vegetation.
Level 3: On a few days a week.
Applies to: ASC (aquaculture)
Salmon hatch and grow up in freshwater tanks and then live in net pens in the sea. ASC salmon is at level 3 because salmon are farmed this way, not because ASC requires the sea.
The ASC Salmon and Cod Standard v1.5 applies to salmon 'farmed in all marine locations', has its own section for smolt suppliers (section 8) and extra rules for open net pens. This level comes from how salmon are farmed, which is our reading of the system; no ASC rule obliges a farm to keep fish outdoors. Spanish law asks nothing here, which is level 1.
Level 4: On almost every day.
Applies to: Wild catch with no label and MSC
Outside in natural water during the whole growing time: this is how wild fish live.
This is our own reading of biology; no rule says it.
What stays open
ASC sets no outdoor rule. ASC salmon is at level 3 because salmon grow up in net pens in the sea, which comes from the farming system.
Further reading
Sources
- Everything on Fish
- How old are fish when they are killed for food?
- Do farmed fish ever see their parents?
- How much space do farmed fish have?
- What does a farmed fish's habitat look like?
- What treatments do farmed fish get?
- How long are live fish transported?
- How are fish killed?
- Label: Wild catch
- Label: Legal minimum
- Label: ASC (Aquaculture Stewardship Council)
- Label: Organic (EU)
- Legal minimum vs Organic (EU): Fish