Beef · Freedom of movement
How much space does a fattening bull have?
Usual: no area is set for adult cattle, and some stand tied. Furthest along: Ecológico (EU organic). Weakest: Conventional (legal minimum) and Welfair.
Why it is like this
RD 348/2000 gives no area for adult cattle. EU organic gives 5 square metres indoors and 3.7 outdoors for a bull over 350 kg and bans tying except on farms of up to 50 cattle with pasture access. Calves in groups need 1.5 to 1.8 square metres.
What the labels say
| Standard | Level |
|---|---|
| Conventional (legal minimum) | 1 Stand up and lie down again |
| Welfair | 1 Stand up and lie down again |
| Ecológico (EU organic) | 1-3 level 1 guaranteed (Stand up and lie down again); up to level 3 depending on the farm |
How we read the levels
- Stand up and lie down again.
- Turn around and stretch out its whole body.
- Walk around without getting in anyone's way.
- Run and play.
Level 1: Stand up and lie down again.
Applies to: Conventional (legal minimum), Welfair and Ecológico (EU organic)
No area is set for adult cattle in Spanish law, and tying is not banned. Calves in groups need 1.5 to 1.8 square metres.
RD 348/2000 Annex I 4: freedom of movement must not be limited so as to cause needless suffering, tethered animals need suitable space; no area is given. RD 1047/1994 Art. 3.3 b: 1.5 m2 per calf under 150 kg, 1.7 m2 to 220 kg, 1.8 m2 above. Where the law says nothing, the level is 1.
Level 3: Walk around without getting in anyone's way.
Possible on some farms, not guaranteed: Ecológico (EU organic)
EU organic gives a bull over 350 kg 5 square metres inside and 3.7 outside. Tying is banned, except on farms of up to 50 cattle with pasture access.
Reg 2020/464 Annex I Part I: over 350 kg live weight 5 m2 indoors (at least 1 m2 per 100 kg) and 3.7 m2 outdoors; Art. 4: at least half of the indoor area solid. Reg 2018/848 Annex II Part II 1.7.5: tethering banned, but authorities may allow it on farms with at most 50 animals if they have pasture or open air twice a week. A class of farms with an exception sets the low end, so organic sits between level 1 and level 3.
What stays open
The B+ beef seal (PAWS) publishes no space rule. At least the legal minimum applies. The B+ seal shows only that an audit exists; its written criteria are not public, so we do not score it. Welfair is in the table, at least at the legal values: it scores the animals' state, and we have not read its prerequisite checklist for this species.
Videos
Note: this video shows images some people find distressing.
Industrial livestock farming, animal welfare and the future of agricultureDW Documental, 32 minDW documentary with three views of intensive livestock farming, including a pig farmer who opens his barns.
Mega-farms: farmers, neighbours and Brussels respond to the controversyRTVE Noticias, 88 sRTVE news item from January 2022 on the mega-farm controversy with farmers, neighbours and the EU.
Mega-farms are fantastic. Or are they?Greenpeace España, 4 minGreenpeace Spain, an environmental group, contrasts mega-farm advertising with what lies behind it.
Further reading
Sources
- Real Decreto 348/2000, farm animals in general (BOE)
- Real Decreto 1047/1994, calves (BOE)
- Implementing Regulation (EU) 2020/464, organic stocking densities (EUR-Lex)
- Regulation (EU) 2018/848, organic production, Annex II (EUR-Lex)
- Welfair certification page (animalwelfair.com)
- Provacuno B+ PAWS page, beef (provacuno.es)
- Everything on Beef
- How long do beef bulls live?
- How long do calves stay with their mother?
- What do beef cattle lie on?
- Do beef cattle get out to pasture?
- Are cattle dehorned?
- How long are cattle transported to slaughter?
- How are cattle slaughtered?
- Label: Legal minimum
- Label: Welfair
- Label: Organic (EU)
- Legal minimum vs Organic (EU): Beef
- Legal minimum vs Welfair: Beef
- Organic (EU) vs Welfair: Beef