How my food lives
Sweden
SVEN

Comparisons

EU organic without KRAV vs MSC (wild fish): which is better for the animal?

Last updated: November 2026

EU organic without KRAV and MSC (wild fish) compared for fish: on 1 of 8 questions EU organic without KRAV is higher, on 4 MSC (wild fish) is higher, on 1 they are equal, 2 cannot be compared. The guaranteed level is compared.

QuestionEU organic without KRAVMSC (wild fish)Result
Lifespan11-4same guaranteed level, range differs
Mother and young14higher: MSC (wild fish)
Freedom of movement24higher: MSC (wild fish)
Resting place?4not comparable
Outdoors?4not comparable
Physical interventions24higher: MSC (wild fish)
The final journey14higher: MSC (wild fish)
Death21higher: EU organic without KRAV

Level 1 is the lowest, the top level of the question is the best. A range such as 2-3 means our sources do not settle on one level.

Where the two differ

Lifespan

EU organic without KRAV: Level 1

No rule we read sets an age or a size at slaughter for farmed fish, so Swedish law and organic farming sit at rung 1. Swedish fish farmers give an average slaughter weight of 2.5 to 3 kg for rainbow trout and 0.5 to 1 kg for Arctic char, 3 to 4 years after the egg. Svenskt Sigill gets the same rung, at least the law, because only its slaughter rule was read. ASC salmon sits here too: its salmon standard sets no age, and neither does Norwegian law, where it is farmed. Wild catch and MSC start at this rung: no rule sets an age, and a wild fish may be caught young or old.

MSC (wild fish): Level 1 to 4

Depends on the fish: level 1 to 4. Only level 1 is guaranteed (Until it is big enough to be used. It may still be very young).

Mother and young

EU organic without KRAV: Level 1

Farmed fish hatch in a hatchery and grow up without their parents. Swedish law has no rule on it, and organic farming asks only for organic parent fish. Svenskt Sigill gets the same rung, at least the law, because only its slaughter rule was read. ASC salmon sits here too: it hatches in a hatchery, and neither its standard nor Norwegian law has a rule on it.

MSC (wild fish): Level 4

A wild fish spawns in the sea, a lake or a river, and the young grow up there. Wild catch with or without MSC sits here by the nature of the animal.

Freedom of movement

EU organic without KRAV: Level 2

KRAV and EU organic cap farmed fish by weight per cubic metre of water: rainbow trout and Arctic charr 25 kg, salmon in fresh water 20 kg, salmon in sea net pens 10 kg. The fish can turn round, but this is a ceiling, not a promise of room. ASC salmon sits here too: its standard sets no density, but Norwegian law, where it is farmed, caps sea pens at 25 kg per cubic metre.

MSC (wild fish): Level 4

A wild fish swims free in open water until it is caught. Wild catch with or without MSC sits here by the nature of the animal.

Physical interventions

EU organic without KRAV: Level 2

Swedish law allows operative interventions on fish only for veterinary reasons, with exceptions. Trained persons may mark fish with a transponder or clip the fat fin, and the fish must be anaesthetised for it. Organic farming adds no ban, so it sits here too. Svenskt Sigill gets the same rung, at least the law, because only its slaughter rule was read.

MSC (wild fish): Level 4

Nothing is done to a wild fish before it is caught. Injuries from the net are not counted here. Wild catch with or without MSC sits at this rung.

The final journey

EU organic without KRAV: Level 1

No rule we read sets a travel time for live farmed fish. Regulation 1/2005 sets travel times only for horses, cattle, sheep, goats and pigs, and organic rules say only that the trip is kept short, without a figure. Svenskt Sigill gets the same rung, at least the law, because only its slaughter rule was read. ASC sets no travel time either, and the Norwegian rules we read set none for fish.

MSC (wild fish): Level 4

A wild fish is not carried alive to a slaughterhouse. It dies at sea or on board, so there is no last trip to rate.

Death

EU organic without KRAV: Level 2

Farmed fish must be stunned before they are killed. In Sweden that happens before the throat is cut, and consciousness must not return. Organic farming asks for a method that makes the fish unconscious at once. No written check of the stun is asked, and nothing is written on fear beforehand. ASC salmon sits here too: its salmon standard has no stunning rule, and the stricter ASC Farm Standard binds every farm only from 1 May 2028. Norwegian law, where the salmon is farmed, requires stunning.

MSC (wild fish): Level 1

No rule we read asks that a wild-caught fish is stunned. The Swedish stunning rule does not cover wild catch, MSC sets no rule on how the catch is killed, and KRAV lets a fish sit up to 24 hours in a net or on a hook. Death in the net without stunning is the hardest point for wild fish.

More on this

Sources