How my food lives
New Zealand
EN

Label

Barn and free range eggs (legal): what it means for the animals

Last updated: November 2026

Barn and free range eggs (legal) appears in our table for one product (eggs). For the first one, eggs, a level is documented for 8 of 8 questions, 2 of them at level 3 or higher.

Barn and free range eggs (legal): Eggs

StandardLifespanMother and youngFreedom of movementResting placeOutdoorsPhysical interventionsThe final journeyDeath
Barn eggs, no outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code)21131112
Free range eggs, barn with outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code)21233112

Level 1 is the lowest, the top level of the question is the best. A range such as 2-3 means our sources do not settle on one level. ? = no fixed rule.

Lifespan (Barn eggs, no outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code) and Free range eggs, barn with outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code)): Level 2

A laying hen is slaughtered or culled when she is spent. The Commercial Slaughter Code says older culled laying birds are slaughtered as well. They are grown but not old, so every egg row sits here. AsureQuality organic sets no age for laying hens either.

Mother and young (Barn eggs, no outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code) and Free range eggs, barn with outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code)): Level 1

For every egg on sale, organic and free range included, the hen hatches in a hatchery. She never sees her mother. This holds for barn and free range eggs under the Layer Hens Code too. AsureQuality organic lets pullets come from conventional rearing when they are under 18 weeks old (5.17.1.1).

Freedom of movement (Barn eggs, no outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code)): Level 1

In a colony cage each hen has at least 750 square centimetres, a little over one sheet of A4 paper. The cage must be at least 45 centimetres high. A legal barn without outdoor access may hold 7 hens per square metre (Layer Hens Code, Minimum Standard 6(b)). That is more room than a colony cage but there is no run, so it falls between rungs 1 and 2 and we give it the lower one. SPCA Certified barn has the same 7 hens per square metre, so it sits here too. The Code does not say whether the square metre is floor or usable area in a multi-tier barn.

Resting place (Barn eggs, no outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code) and Free range eggs, barn with outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code)): Level 3

SPCA Certified requires dry, loose litter over the whole usable floor, kept at 5 to 10 centimetres average depth, and 15 centimetres of perch per hen. BioGro organic asks for natural bedding where animals need it, and the Layer Hens Code requires litter for every barn hen, so BioGro sits here. The Layer Hens Code requires good, friable litter for every barn hen at all times and perches where all birds can sit at once (Minimum Standard 4). Legal barn and free range eggs sit here. AsureQuality organic does too: at least a third of the floor is solid and covered with litter, with 18 centimetres of perch per bird (5.17.4.1, 5.17.5.4).

Outdoors (Barn eggs, no outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code)): Level 1

In a colony cage or a barn, a hen never goes outside. SPCA Certified barn eggs come from systems with no outdoor range. A legal barn without outdoor access sits here as well.

Physical interventions (Barn eggs, no outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code) and Free range eggs, barn with outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code)): Level 1

Beak tipping is allowed up to 3 days of age by regulation, and SPCA Certified allows infra-red treatment at the hatchery as well as later tipping on veterinary advice. Organic (BioGro) bans debeaking on the farm, but chicks up to 2 days old may come from any source, so a hen tipped at the hatchery is not excluded. All egg rows sit here. Legal barn and free range eggs follow the same regulation. AsureQuality organic bans hot beak trimming but says infra-red tipping at the hatchery is not a mutilation (5.11.2, 5.17.6.12), so it sits here too.

The final journey (Barn eggs, no outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code) and Free range eggs, barn with outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code)): Level 1

No law caps the trip for a hen, so colony cage eggs sit here. For organic the trip normally stays under 8 hours, but BioGro may allow a longer one in writing, so BioGro sits between 1 and 2. Legal barn and free range eggs have no time limit either. AsureQuality organic caps the trip to slaughter at 8 hours, but may allow a longer one when no organic slaughterhouse is near (5.12.2), so it sits between 1 and 2.

Death (Barn eggs, no outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code) and Free range eggs, barn with outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code)): Level 2

For all egg rows the legal minimum is the rule. The spent hen is stunned and then has her throat cut. SPCA Certified allows only cervical dislocation for euthanasia on the farm and bans induced moulting. AsureQuality organic requires every animal to be stunned before it is bled (5.12.8) and sets no check of the stun, so it sits here with the law.

Freedom of movement (Free range eggs, barn with outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code)): Level 2

At SPCA Certified a hen needs room to turn around, preen, flap and stretch without touching other hens. A barn without range may hold 7 hens per square metre of usable floor, a free-range shed 9. Free range under the Layer Hens Code may hold 9 hens per square metre inside and at most 2,500 hens per hectare of range, about 4 square metres each outside (Minimum Standard 6(b)), so it sits here. SPCA Certified barn also asks for room to flap and stretch without touching other hens and caps a flock at 5,000 birds. Neither sets a lower density than the legal barn, so they do not move it up. BioGro organic sits here at its low end, because the Layer Hens Code caps any barn with outdoor access at 9 hens per square metre.

Outdoors (Free range eggs, barn with outdoor access (legal minimum, Layer Hens Code)): Level 3

Free range at SPCA Certified means unrestricted access for at least eight hours of daylight every day. It starts no later than three weeks after nest box training has finished. Free range under the Layer Hens Code must open the range during daylight unless bad weather or a vet prevents it (Minimum Standard 11(d)). The Code sets no number of days and no age at which access starts, so it falls between rungs 3 and 4 and we give it the lower one. AsureQuality organic asks for an open-air run whenever the weather permits (5.17.4.5) and names no number of days either, so it sits here too. This standard applies until 31 March 2028, when the Organic Standards Regulations 2025 take over for every product sold as organic.

More on this

Sources