Fish ยท Death
How are fish killed?
No fish product reaches a death without fear. Furthest along: EU Organic aquaculture (Irish organic salmon, Irish Organic Association). Weakest: 4 standards, among them Wild fish without label and Wild fish with MSC label.
Why it is like this
EU law does not require fish to be stunned, only that avoidable pain be spared. Wild fish mostly die in the net, in the air or on ice. Organic farmed fish must be rendered unconscious immediately, which is the best written rule we found.
What the labels say
| Standard | Level |
|---|---|
| Wild fish without label | 1 I don't care how it dies |
| Wild fish with MSC label | 1 I don't care how it dies |
| Farmed salmon, legal minimum | 1 I don't care how it dies |
| Farmed salmon with ASC label | 1 I don't care how it dies |
| EU Organic aquaculture (Irish organic salmon, Irish Organic Association) | 2-3 level 2 guaranteed (It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick); up to level 3 depending on the farm |
How we read the levels
- I don't care how it dies.
- It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick.
- It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand.
- It should die without fear and without pain, and notice nothing of it.
Level 1: I don't care how it dies.
Applies to: Wild fish without label, Wild fish with MSC label, Farmed salmon, legal minimum and Farmed salmon with ASC label
EU law does not require fish to be stunned. Wild-caught fish mostly die in the net, in the air or on ice, and that can take a long time. Farmed fish are killed at slaughter, also with no duty to stun. The MSC label covers wild catch and the ASC label covers farmed fish only; neither changes this.
Regulation 1099/2009, Art. 1(1): as regards fish, only Article 3(1) applies, which says to spare avoidable pain, with no duty to stun. S.I. 311/2010, regulation 5(2), leaves fish out as well. The German table counts farmed fish at 2 because German law requires stunning. Ireland has no such rule that we found, so the legal row is 1. The ASC Salmon and Cod Standard V1.5 has no stunning or slaughter rule. We did not open the MSC rules.
Level 2: It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick.
Applies to: EU Organic aquaculture (Irish organic salmon, Irish Organic Association)
Organic aquaculture rules require slaughter techniques that make fish unconscious at once. We place organic between 2 and 3 and score it at 2.
Regulation 2018/848, Annex II Part III 3.1.6.9: "Slaughter techniques shall render fish immediately unconscious and insensible to pain."
Level 3: It should feel no pain, even if it may be afraid beforehand.
Possible on some farms, not guaranteed: EU Organic aquaculture (Irish organic salmon, Irish Organic Association)
Stunning with an effectiveness check: organic rules go toward this level, but they do not state a check. No label we opened is placed here with certainty.
The new ASC Farm Standard (version 1.0.1A2, 5 August 2026, programme-centre.asc-aqua.org/farm-v1/farm-standard/) has stunning rules, but it becomes mandatory only on 1 May 2028: every audit before that date can still be against the older Salmon and Cod Standard V1.5, which has none, and a pack does not show which one applies. So ASC salmon stays at level 1 here. The ASC claims in the German table (95 out of 100 fish unconscious immediately, no CO2 or suffocation) are not used for Ireland.
Sources
- Regulation (EC) No 1099/2009, killing (EUR-Lex)
- S.I. No. 311/2010, Welfare of farmed animals Regulations (Irish Statute Book)
- ASC Salmon and Cod Standard (ASC-STD-010) V1.5 (PDF)
- Regulation (EU) 2018/848, organic production (EUR-Lex)
- Carried over from the German table (not re-opened for Ireland)
- Everything on Fish
- How old are fish when they are killed for food?
- Do farmed fish ever see their parents?
- How much space do farmed fish have?
- What does a farmed fish's habitat look like?
- Do farmed fish live outdoors?
- What treatments do farmed fish get?
- How long are live fish transported?
- Label: Wild catch
- Label: Farmed salmon (net pens)
- Label: EU organic (Irish certifying bodies)