How my food lives
Canada
EN

Comparisons

Legal minimum (federal law) vs Wild-caught salmon: which is better for the animal?

Last updated: November 2026

Legal minimum (federal law) and Wild-caught salmon compared for fish: of 8 questions, Legal minimum (federal law) is higher on none, Wild-caught salmon is higher on 6, they are equal on 2. The guaranteed level is compared.

QuestionLegal minimum (federal law)Wild-caught salmonResult
Lifespan11-4same guaranteed level, range differs
Mother and young14higher: Wild-caught salmon
Freedom of movement14higher: Wild-caught salmon
Resting place14higher: Wild-caught salmon
Outdoors14higher: Wild-caught salmon
Physical interventions14higher: Wild-caught salmon
The final journey14higher: Wild-caught salmon
Death11equal

Level 1 is the lowest, the top level of the question is the best. A range such as 2-3 means our sources do not settle on one level.

Where the two differ

Lifespan

Legal minimum (federal law): Level 1

No rule sets a slaughter age for farmed salmon, and no label we read does either, so every row is at Level 1. Salmon grow 15 to 24 months in sea cages after the hatchery. Wild-caught salmon may be caught young or old, so its range starts here.

Wild-caught salmon: Level 1 to 4

Depends on the fish: level 1 to 4. Only level 1 is guaranteed (Until it is big enough to be used. It may still be very young).

Mother and young

Legal minimum (federal law): Level 1

Farmed salmon hatch in a hatchery, where eggs are collected from broodfish by hand. The Code has rules for hatchery stages and none on contact between parents and young.

Wild-caught salmon: Level 4

The natural state: wild fish spawn in the sea or in rivers, and the young grow up there. This applies to wild-caught fish.

Freedom of movement

Legal minimum (federal law): Level 1

The law and ASC set no cap on how many fish go in a pen. The voluntary salmonid Code, which has no row here, describes maximum densities of about 10 to 25 kg per cubic metre in net pens. We count Level 1.

Wild-caught salmon: Level 4

A wild fish swims free in open water. This applies to wild-caught fish.

Resting place

Legal minimum (federal law): Level 1

The law and ASC require no resting structures in a net pen. The voluntary Code, which has no row here, only recommends shelters or substrates for tanks. We count Level 1.

Wild-caught salmon: Level 4

Wild fish choose among natural structures such as reef, weed and sea floor. This applies to wild-caught fish.

Outdoors

Legal minimum (federal law): Level 1

No rule we read requires outdoor water or daylight for farmed fish. The Code only names the systems used: net pens, lake net pens and land tanks.

Wild-caught salmon: Level 4

Outdoors for the whole life. This applies to wild-caught fish only.

Physical interventions

Legal minimum (federal law): Level 1

The law and ASC set no rule on these procedures. The voluntary Code, which has no row here, allows fin clipping, tagging and scale scrapes, with sedation or anesthesia as directed by the farm veterinarian. We count Level 1.

Wild-caught salmon: Level 4

Wild fish are not handled until they are caught. Injuries from nets are not counted here.

The final journey

Legal minimum (federal law): Level 1

The law sets no limit on hours in transport that we found, and ASC adds none. The voluntary Code, which has no row here, also sets no limit; it caps loading at 150 kg of fish per cubic metre and asks for lower densities when transport lasts over 8 hours. We count Level 1.

Wild-caught salmon: Level 4

Wild fish do not travel alive before they are caught. This applies to wild-caught fish.

More on this

Sources