Comparisons
MSC (wild fish) vs ASC (farmed fish): which is better for the animal?
MSC (wild fish) and ASC (farmed fish) compared for fish: on 6 of 8 questions MSC (wild fish) is higher, on 1 ASC (farmed fish) is higher, on 1 they are equal. The guaranteed level is compared.
| Question | MSC (wild fish) | ASC (farmed fish) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lifespan | 1-4 | 1-2 | same guaranteed level, range differs |
| Mother and young | 4 | 1 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Freedom of movement | 4 | 1 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Resting place | 4 | 1 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Outdoors | 4 | 3-4 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Physical interventions | 4 | 2 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| The final journey | 4 | 1 | higher: MSC (wild fish) |
| Death | 1 | 2-3 | higher: ASC (farmed fish) |
Level 1 is the lowest, the top level of the question is the best. A range such as 2-3 means our sources do not settle on one level.
Where the two differ
Lifespan
MSC (wild fish): Level 1 to 4
Depends on the fish: level 1 to 4. Only level 1 is guaranteed (Until it is big enough to be used. It may still be very young).
ASC (farmed fish): Level 1 to 2
Depending on the farm, level 1 to 2. Only level 1 is guaranteed (Until it is big enough to be used. It may still be very young).
Mother and young
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
The natural state: a wild fish spawns in the sea or river, and the young grow up there. This applies to wild fish without a label and with MSC.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 1
The eggs are taken from the parent animals and hatched in a hatchery, and the young fish never see their parents. This is the case for farmed salmon, ASC and EU organic.
Freedom of movement
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
A spacious pond in which at least half of the food comes from natural food, or the open sea. That is the position for wild fish and for BIO AUSTRIA organic carp ponds.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 1
For conventional farmed salmon our sources give no limit. For ASC we found no stocking density.
Resting place
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
Several natural structures to choose from: wild fish in the sea have this, and so do fish in an organic pond with reeds, plants and earth floor.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 1
A net pen in the sea or a tank without structures: the salmon swims in a net cage, and the floor is not natural. This is the case for farmed salmon and ASC.
Outdoors
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
Outside in natural water for the whole growing time: that is the position for BIO AUSTRIA carp ponds and for wild fish.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 3 to 4
Depending on the farm, level 3 to 4. Only level 3 is guaranteed (On a few days a week).
Physical interventions
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
Nothing is done to the animal: this is the wild fish until it is caught. Injuries from nets and bycatch are not counted here.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 2
Routine treatments are banned, handling and medicines under a plan remain allowed: that is the position under BIO AUSTRIA, organic (EU), Naturland and ASC.
The final journey
MSC (wild fish): Level 4
No transport of live fish: the wild fish dies in the net or on board. It reaches land dead or dying.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 1
Live fish may be transported for more than 8 hours. Naturland allows up to 10 hours, and in a well boat (Wellboot) up to 72 hours. This is where Naturland aquaculture, ASC and Organic (EU) aquaculture sit.
Death
MSC (wild fish): Level 1
Most wild-caught fish are crushed in the net, suffocate in air, are put on ice or gutted alive. That holds for wild catch without a label and with MSC. The MSC label has no rule on this either.
ASC (farmed fish): Level 2 to 3
Depending on the farm, level 2 to 3. Only level 2 is guaranteed (It may feel brief fear or pain if it is quick).
Sources
- Wild catch: the fish lives free in the sea, a lake or a river until it is caught
- Wild catch: the fish lives free until it is caught; it may be caught young or old, and no rule sets an age (biology, no rule)
- Rung copied from the German table (there based on EU law, a label text or biology, partly without a source of its own; not re-checked for Austria)
- MSC standard (no rule on killing the fish)
- AMA-Gütesiegel guideline for fish and fish products, version 2015/1
- Norway: Akvakulturdriftsforskriften (FOR-2008-06-17-822), Norwegian aquaculture regulation, as read for our Norway table (no hour limit for transporting live fish)
- Norway: Forskrift om næringsmessig transport av dyr (FOR-2012-02-08-139), Norwegian animal transport regulation, as read for our Norway table
- ASC Salmon Standard v1.4 (September 2022), as read for our Norway table: no hour limit for transport; the origin of the ASC salmon sold in Austria is not sourced, and its law was not checked
- fishcount.org.uk
- epub.sub.uni-hamburg.de
- fishcount.org.uk
- faunalytics.org